Abstract: The argument of this lecture runs against the widely accepted apocalyptic portrayal of the Middle East as “disintegrating” according to which the rise of politicized Islam is either a manifestation or a cause. A closer look shows that despite the bloody conflicts in three major countries in the region, more than ten other countries, including those lying in the vicinity of the war theaters have kept their political and societal fabric relatively stable.
What we are witnessing today is rather a bloody round of negotiation reflecting the changing power relations among the major actors within the respective societies with the aim of reestablishing and configuring their states that have hitherto drawn their legitimization from the concept of ethnic nationalism. Politicizing religion has been part and parcel of the processes of nation-formation in most of Europe and the United States and politicizing Islam today seems no exception. Apart from the Kurds’ long time aspiration to establish their own independent state in Iraq and an autonomous entity in Syria, the warring parties are striving to lay hand on the central power rather than carving out mini-states of their own.
Dr Isam al Khafaji leads a research team on the Middle East Interstate System. He taught at the University of Amsterdam and was a visiting professor at Yale University and New York University and was a distinguished research fellow at Brown University and New York University. Al Khafaji is an adjunct scholar at the Middle East Institute (Washington DC) and a contributing editor of “Middle East Report.” He is the author of the academically acclaimed “Tormented Births: Passages to Modernity in Europe and the Middle East.” (Translated into Arabic by the Egyptian National Center of Translation). Al Khafaji served as the senior expert to the UNDP for launching Syria’s first Human Development Report. He was the senior advisor to the UN envoy to supervise Iraq’s transition from the US led Coalition to Iraqi sovereignty.
- Toby Dodge (2016) The Danger of Analogical Myths: Explaining the Power and Consequences of the Sykes-Picot Delusion, Symposium on The Many Lives and Legacies of Sykes-Picot, The London School of Economics.
- Aslı Bâli (2016) Sykes- Picot and the “Artificial” States, Ibid.
- Paul Salem, The Disintegration of the Levant, The Middle East Carnegie Center, Jan. 24, 2013.
- Robert D. Caplan, The Ruins of Empire in the Middle East, Foreign Policy, May 25, 2015.
- Philip Gordon, The Middle East Is Falling Apart, Politico, June 4, 2015.
- William Reno 2000 Shadow States and the Political Economy of Civil Wars, in Mats Berdel and David M. Malone (eds.) Greed and Grievance: Economic Agendas in Civil Wars, London, Lynne Rienner Publishers: 43-69.
- Adrian Hastings 1997 The Construction of Nationhood: Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Chapter 8: Religion further Considered: 185-210.